[CCP14 Home: (Frames | No Frames)]
CCP14 Mirrors: [UK] | [CA] | [US] | [AU]

(This Webpage Page in No Frames Mode)

CCP14

Tutorials and Examples

CRYSFIRE Powder Indexing System for DOS/Windows by Robin Shirley et al

Basic Demonstration of CRYSFIRE Powder Indexing System with 20 peaks and greater, including the use of the new MMAP routine

The CCP14 Homepage is at http://www.ccp14.ac.uk

[Tutorials page] | [CRYSFIRE Tutorial Index] | [Crysfire What's New] | [LMGP Suite Chekcell Index] | [Powder Diffraction Indexing Resources]

Obtaining and installing CRYSFIRE

NOTE: A graphical program for MS-Windows that links into CRYSFIRE to help check trial cells and determine spacegroups is the Chekcell software - part of the LMGP suite for Windows by Jean Laugier and Bernard Bochu.


Note: The following is just a single example of using CRYSFIRE. There are other methods of interacting with the program and doing the following. The assumption is that you have got your peaks / observations into a Crysfire CDT file (via some of the other tutorials).

This run through will use the peak list file obtained in the Lithium Titanate Fundamental Parameters Peak Profiling Tutorial. (I.E. Grey, L. M. D. Cranswick, C. Li, L. A. Bursill, and J. L. Peng, "New Phases Formed in the Li-Ti-O System under Reducing Conditions", Journal of Solid State Chemistry, 138, 74-86 (1998))

The strategy here is INdex using all the available programs by using the IN command. By using all the programs, we will then obtain a good idea at the range of possible solutions the data will support. Hopefully one or two of those solutions will appear superior compared to the great mass of other trial cells.

The following assumes you have already created a Crysfire CDT file. Example tutorials for importing data into Crysfire are:


A comment from Robin Shirley about filenames and descriptive text

From: Robin Shirley [[email protected]]
Organization: Psychology Dept, Surrey Univ. U.K.
To: Lachlan Cranswick [[email protected]]
Date: Mon, 22 Jul 2002 18:43:55 GMT

Incidentally, in this context, could you please emphasise in your
tutorials the importance of spending the few seconds that it takes to
give each new dataset a well-chosen name and some helpful brief
descriptive text in its description field, seeing that whatever is used
there will remain the default throughout the rest of the analysis?

Careful dataset naming really is important for keeping track of progress
in any serious study that can involve several dataset variants, and
such distinctive names have been assumed throughout Crysfire as the basis 
of its data organisation.

Users shouldn't rely just on having kept each problem separate within
its own data directory (folder).

While that's important, it's *not* sufficient, because (a) doing that
only identifies the directory, not the files within it, and (b) as the
study progresses, it's likely that several datasets and dataset variants
will be required, for example after recalibration, applying estimated
Z2theta or specimen-displacement corrections, rescaling, etc.

These will all need to be kept in the same directory so that, for
example, their trial cells can easily be loaded and examined (LC, M1,
etc), but if they aren't given different names (and preferably also
different description fields - see below) then complete confusion will
quickly result.

Since the description field gets appended to every summary-file solution 
line, an important opportunity is lost if its contents can't act as an 
aide memoire of the characteristics of the particular dataset or dataset
variant that was used for that trial solution.

This becomes particularly relevant when datasets are merged and/or
rescaling/unscaling is used, as was discussed above and as is
increasingly likely to happen in response to the new volume estimates
and rescaling prompts in CF2002.

I'm already regretting that I short-sightedly left it far too easy in
WF2crys and XF2crys for users to default to an undistinctive and
meaningless dataset name like Crys.cdt (I've noticed that you are 
yourself a frequent offender in this regard!), and I may well look at 
ways to prevent this in the next revisions of those programs.

As things stand, it's too easy for a moment's impatience on the part of
the user at this basic choice point to handicap all subsequent work on
that sample with a basically null name (and description) - I really
should have had the foresight to protect users from this pitfall.

(A bit of a rant, perhaps, but I do think the point needs making.)

With best wishes

Robin


Taup

We may as well start indexing using the Crysfire recommended sequence.

Using the INdex command, select Taup (TP) and go with all the defaults.

Crysfire will tell you which programs have been run already based on the present output files.

Continue on to then view the a) Taup output, b) the Crysfire summary file and c) the LePage reduced cell summary file.

Le Page summary including cells found by  Taup

Crysfire summary file so Far. - Taup


Dicvol - high symmetry mode

After viewing the LePage summary file, Crysfire will return to the main menu ready to index again.

Using the INdex command, select Dicvol high symmetry mode (D1) and go with all the defaults.

This gets around some problems with Dicvol searching out in volume shells and not terminating before reporting the highest symmetry solutions. Unless you have a lot of time, it could be best to avoid trying to using the Triclinic option in Dicvol.

In this example, Dicvol finds no high symmetry solutions, so Crysfire does not show the Crysfire summary file or Le Page output.


ITO

When no solutions are found, Crysfire continues on, in this case, we will run ITO.

Crysfire tries to gives smart defaults. However, other people may give different hints. Based on advice from Armel Le Bail, he suggested to not use more than 25 peaks when starting out. (in this example, there are a total of 34 peaks and Crysfire will recommend we use all of these for Ito)

But for more complicated samples, you may have to interact at a deeper level, entering the "possible number" of spurious peaks, etc). (If prompted, do not apply an extra two-theta offset correction as this has already been included using the self-calibration technique.)

Using the INdex command, select Ito (IT) and go with all the defaults.

Keep pressing [Enter] at the point Crysfire will spawn and run ITO after which it will prompt you to continue on.

Continue on to then view the ITO output, the Crysfire summary file and the LePage reduced cell summary file.

Le Page summary including cells found by  ITO

Crysfire summary file so Far. - Taup, Dicvol - high symmetry, ITO


FJZN

Again, after viewing the LePage summary file, Crysfire will return to the main menu ready to index again.

Using the INdex command, select FJZN (FJ) and go with all the defaults.

Continue on to then view the a) FJZN output, b) the Crysfire summary file and c) the LePage reduced cell summary file.

Le Page summary including cells found by  FJZN

Crysfire summary file so Far. - Taup, Dicvol - high symmetry, ITO, Fjzn


Treor

Again, after viewing the LePage summary file, Crysfire will return to the main menu ready to index again.

Using the INdex command, select Treor (TR) and go with all the defaults.

Continue on to then view the a) Treor output, b) the Crysfire summary file and c) the LePage reduced cell summary file.

Le Page summary including cells found by  Treor

Crysfire summary file so Far. - Taup, Dicvol - high symmetry, ITO, Fjzn, Treor


Kohl

Again, after viewing the LePage summary file, Crysfire will return to the main menu ready to index again.

Using the INdex command, select Kohl (KL) and go with all the defaults. When prompted, go for the the default of indexing all 3 systems (orthorhombic, monoclinic, triclinic)

Continue on to then view the a) Kohl output, b) the Crysfire summary file and c) the LePage reduced cell summary file.

Le Page summary including cells found by  Kohl

Crysfire summary file so Far. - Taup, Dicvol - high symmetry, ITO, Fjzn, Treor, Kohl


Dicvol - low symmetry mode

Again, after viewing the LePage summary file, Crysfire will return to the main menu ready to index again.

Using the INdex command, select Dicvol (high symmetry) (D2) and go with all the defaults. (if prompted to over-write an existing Dicvol file - just type Y for yes)

(Unless you have a lot of time, it could be best to avoid trying to using the Triclinic option in Dicvol - which is one of the non-default options).

Continue on to then view the a) Dicvol output, b) the Crysfire summary file and c) the LePage reduced cell summary file.

Le Page summary including cells found by  Dicvol

Crysfire summary file so Far. - Taup, Dicvol - high symmetry, ITO, Fjzn, Treor, Kohl, Dicvol - low symmetry


Lzon

Again, after viewing the LePage summary file, Crysfire will return to the main menu ready to index again.

Using the INdex command, select Lzon (LZ) and go with all the defaults.

Continue on to then view the a) Lzon output, b) the Crysfire summary file and c) the LePage reduced cell summary file.

Le Page summary including cells found by Lzon

Crysfire summary file so Far. - Taup, Dicvol - high symmetry, ITO, Fjzn, Treor, Kohl, Dicvol - low symmetry, Lzon


As can be seen from the following screen image, the following monoclinic cell is quite popular near the top of the FOM (Figure of Merit):

14.0875   2.9476   4.8992  90.000  92.212  90.000
14.0876   2.9475   4.8992  90.000  92.212  90.000
14.0876   2.9475   4.8992  90.000  92.212  90.000
14.0876   2.9475   4.8992  90.000  92.212  90.000
14.0876   2.9475   4.8992  90.000  92.212  90.000
14.0876   2.9475   4.8992  90.000  92.212  90.000
14.0876   2.9475   4.8992  90.000  92.212  90.000
14.0876   2.9475   4.8992  90.000  92.212  90.000
14.0876   2.9475   4.8992  90.000  92.212  90.000
14.0876   2.9475   4.8992  90.000  92.212  90.000
14.1047   2.9511   4.9051  90.000  92.210  90.000
14.0890   2.9474   4.8988  90.000  92.209  90.000
14.0879   2.9469   4.8988  90.000  92.213  90.000
14.1050   2.9508   4.9054  90.000  92.216  90.000
14.1050   2.9508   4.9054  90.000  92.216  90.000

Thus by getting an overall view of what all the indexing programs are outputting, you can get a better idea of the possible solutions, and possibly focus in on some worth pursuing with Le Bail fitting or with Chekcell graphical indexing helper tool.

A new option in Crysfire 2002 is to try and evaluate solutions is MMAP. The following gives an idea of how to make use of it.


Analyse your results

MMap

Too evalute solutions with MMAP, first make sure you have the relevant CDT file loaded into memory (using the LO command).

Then use the Load Cell command (LC) to load a trial cell into Crysfire's memory. The following screen dump gives the type of prompt you will encounter.

Tell Crysfire you wish to load a cell from the Crysfire summary file on which you will be given the Summary file list.

Crysfire summary list in Load Cell menu


Select Cell the top FOM solution by typing 1. After accepting this and the various Crysfire information, you will be prompted to Display the 3 principal M1-map sections for this cell. Type Y for Yes.

Prompted to Display the 3 principal M1-map sections for this cell

M1 thumbnails for this cell

Following is a MMAP Merit Map from solution 12 (a triclinic cell) it shows two main features and a verticle ridge connecting them - not a good sign of a correct solution. But examining "good" solutions like the above might show interesting MMAP landscape features that should put you on your guard.

Obtaining a Merit Map from MMap - triclinic trial cell


Crysfire Log file

Crysfire creates a Log file of all the major functions you run, opening the relevant *.LOG file will display what you did.

Crysfire LOG file


Analyse your results

Now try Chekcell

Now might be a good time to pass the results over to the Chekcell graphical indexing helper tool by Jean Laugier and Bernard Bochu.

Make sure you peruse the following tutorial: Using Ton Spek's Lepage within Chekcell to find super-cells and better trial cell solutions

Loading the liti solution into Chekcell


[Tutorials page] | [CRYSFIRE Tutorial Index] | [Crysfire What's New] | [LMGP Suite Chekcell Index] | [Powder Diffraction Indexing Resources]

[CCP14 Home: (Frames | No Frames)]
CCP14 Mirrors: [UK] | [CA] | [US] | [AU]

(This Webpage Page in No Frames Mode)

If you have any queries or comments, please feel free to contact the CCP14